Varifocal Lenses

  In the Summer 2002 issue of GASCo Flight Safety a member's letter on the above subject was mis-printed. The full text of this letter follows.

 

Nigel. Mary Meagher wrote in the last issue ("Lookout") that we pilots should not wear Varifocal lenses. I thought it might be useful to add my own experience here, as I don't think the answer is as simple as that.

I started wearing Varifocals many years ago - not because of macho airline pilots!. The choice at the time was bifocals or varifocals. I just could not get away with bifocals - first of all they didn't help the mid-range (looking at computer screens) and secondly they just about ripped your eyeballs out when you went across the transition layer. At the time I was recommended to take glass varifocal lenses mainly because one eye is much worse than the other on long range (short-sighted) and the relevant plastic lens would have been twice as thick. I had no problems with peripheral vision using these glass lenses.

A few years ago I had a prescription change and the optician ordered plastic lenses ("because they are much lighter and really very good these days...") I stressed the requirement for good peripheral vision and was assured there would be no problem. Unfortunately this advice was incorrect - the new plastic lenses caused severe distortion at the periphery and were just no good. They did try another different plastic lens manufacturer, they were just as bad, so I ended up with glass again.

Just last month I had another eye test and although the change was small I ordered new glass lenses (you can do a lot of hours for the price of varifocal lenses!). The new glasses were delivered - with plastic lenses - and with the same unacceptable peripheral distortion. They were immediately handed back for a full refund, and I am now seeking a new optician who can deliver what the customer asks for.

There are some new plastic lenses which cost even more (you're looking at £450 for a pair of glasses, times two to get the requisite spare pair) - if anyone has tried these it would be interesting to hear the results. Meanwhile I'll stick to glass.

Peter Short.